Brian McFadden’s not welcome back in Westlife, says Kian Egan

westlife without Brian it’s not the same ;(

I think Brian should come back for the anniversary as he was part of westlife when they started ok he left but he was the original westlife as a 5 piece.I can also see Kians point he left just before their tour he let them down big time but they still made it a success.Come on westlife have Brian back just for the part he was in westlife and then he can leave you to carry on for the part he left.Bring Brian back for the one off gig at Croke.Yes westlife are better without him but you cant forget he gave westlife 6yrs.

Well I have one thing to say . I like westlife
but since I saw Brian and Delta it really felt wright those two together. It seems he changed in a very positive way. Kian on the other hand
I feel sorry for you , it must feel hard not be
able to give someone a second change. Life is about giving and forgiving. Seems to me you still in learning process. Anyway still love ya!
Oh my favourite group is Take That maybe you can learn something from them about forgiviness!
Love Ellen Belguim

I think westlife are much better without Brian, a band is a responsability you cant go and come back when you want to. The lads made a big effort and worked so hard to give their best to the fans when Brian left, they don’t deserve that Brian comes back again, they care their job more than Brian did!

it’s not real and true
sorry 4 u

I’m a Canadian, and A BIG WESTLIFE FAN. I have been a fan since the beginning. They are not very well known out here but they have released a few albums out here in their earlier days.

Brian made his bed…now he has to sleep in it. He said originally at the press conference that he was leaving because he wanted to look after his children and his then-wife, Kerry Katona but really he wanted to have his cake and eat it too by starting a solo career that was a MAJOR flop. Now he expects, that since things didn’t go the way he planned that Westlife should welcome him back with open arms? Good on the other lads for saying HELL NO.

I applaud them. I kinda think Westlife is better off without him anyway…they have grown and evolved since he left, have gotten a more mature sound. I have 7/8 Westlife albums and the comparison between the ones with Brian and the ones without can definately tell there is a difference. They weren’t bad with Brian, I just think they’ve become better without him. Face it Brian, you don’t know what you got until it’s gone. Sad world.

I think Westlife must let Bryan in! What’s the difference? We need him back like next year when Westlife want to releasing a new album. It’s not impossible!

Hi,goodjob.I agree with you

I think Brian should be giving a chance. He was too young 2 think he can survive without westlife.They should let him in maybe in 2009 when they will be releasing a new album.Amagine how much album they will sell when Brian comes back,becus everyone will want 2 see westlife again with Brian.They should pity him,and now he know`s he was soo stupid to have left WESTLIFE.

I didn’t know Brian left Westlife until last year and I cried for some minutes. Brian was my favourite and I think he didn’t know what he was doing at first. Now, if he has realise that he need westlife in his life, I think westlife should accept him back.

And one more thing, we need Westlife in Toronto. We’ve miss you Brian.

yeh
me 2
WSTLYF RULE $ EVA

i love westlife toooooooooo much

i love shain its sooo cute and idont care jast shain is raight and iam 15 years old

loooooovvvve you shaaaaain you are a best of my hart

He is shite.

you are a son of b***h

Go Westlife! and hope too Brian can back the band. He’s doing good after the years. Its much better if westlife group were reuniting again including Brian. Hope Brian can back. Please back Brian, we’ll miss ur voice in the westlife band. and hope too (4)westlife can accept back Brian. “hope,hope… million times.” We love u Brian and Shane and Mark and Kian and Nicky.love u guys.
Brian, dont make songs bad title like demon.

hi…. idol i miss u 2 pls come here to phillippines byeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

hi westlife i love u 2 so much see u later bryan god blees

hi westlife how are u now pls come to phillippines byeeeeeeeeeeeeeee i love u 2 so much westlife

westlife
love
westlife

I think that Westlife would be better without Brian cause Brian is with Delta Goodrem now and he sings with her and yeh that is cool, them 2 and their the best couple:)
Westlife sucks!

I love all westlife members (including Bryan)expect Kian , Shane ,Mark & Bryan were the real foreground singers of westlife and we love it ,Now Kian who sings the background with all others say so ,He is not at all good!

to be honest i can see it from both point of views, brian left westlife just before a tour and they had to sort it out with out him, i was heartbroken when he left thinking that they would split up, but they didnt and look how far they have come without him. however, brian was there at the beginning and was an initial part of westlife. if it was up to me though, i reckon they should just carry on without him, and maybe he could join them on stage for a few songs, like flying without wings for example.

hii i think westlife is better with brian because he is a good singer and everybody shoud have a secend chance

that was a bit harsh
i luvvvvvvvvv wstlyf but dat was a bit mean

Allô, I’m Canadian (québécoise) and I want to say that Westlife is better with Brian McFadden.
Brian have a good voice, and his voice is a bit kind of sweet and cute.
It’s really sad to see only 4 members on the band, they must let Brian back into Westlife!
Please!!! SHANE, NICKY, MARK & KIAN!!! Bring him back! He was just a little bit dummy to quite the band but now, I think he understands.

Please!!! SHANE, NICKY, MARK & KIAN!!! Bring him back!

please, please, please. let brian back
with him all of u can be best in the world again.
please, please, please.
im indonesian.
indonesian like all of you as in the first time when you launched your album.
i wait you until im dying.

westlife……………………………………
I love you so much…
but I like if brian join westlife again

“Look At Me! I Am Going Solo because I Am THAT Good! Oh Snap! Looks like I Am Rubbish After All And Only A Few Simpletons Give A Toss For My Flat, Whiney-Voiced Efforts, No-one Else Cares And It Is All Looking Like An EPIC FAIL!!…”

Well, he made his bed. Now he can lie in it.
If he had gone triple platinum worldwide he wouldn’t be wanting back in so he should get some self-respect and crack on with something else.

He’ll probably be happier and it’ll be less shameful anyway. Who wants to be known as “That one who FAILED and had to come crawling back” and have to explain how you didn’t fail really and you always were going to come back and it was all part of the plan anyway, and do that in every single interview, for the rest of your damn life? Jerk.

In fact, he’d be a two-time loser if they let him back as the reason he left in first place still apply. Ie; Westlife, as an idea and as an actual product, are nothing more than a cynical mockery, designed only to relieve idiots of their pocket-money.

Ha, ha, ha. Fools.

hei, let him back.
without brian westlife is decrease in fans.
In the last time when there is brian all could be best.

i am a big fan of westlife. i have loved them since they started as a band.. when brian left, i cried. i cried because it seemed then that westlife wouldn’t be the same again. for me they are not complete anymore. and for that i am one of those people who want brian mcfadden to be back in the band. if you listen to westlife albums launched without brian, you’ll notice there’s something missing.i honestly can not explain what is that.. but if you are really a fan and you listen to their songs through your heart you’ll notice it too.. admit it lads, the magic of westlife lessened when brian left. he is one wonderful buddy, specially his voice..so i’m begging mark,kian,nicky and shane to accept him again. yes, you survived without him,but you are wonderful if you are complete. and without brian you are not complete. one more thing, i know what he did was somewhat stupid, leaving the band i mean. but we, your fans will be very happy if we see you guys complete again. you are wonderful and definitely the best when you are altogether. please,please,please…we want westlife to be complete again!!!

Brian is soo cute…please give him a chance to be part of WESTLIFE again…He has a good reason why he left..and probably his life belongs to westlife because for me WESTLIFE is never be the same again without BRIAN.Thank you.

please let him to back.if yo don’t do it,you are not complete any more and amazing like before.so please let him.

i hope million times about it and kevin leaves mark.

Come on, take him back.. we want to see Westlife with 5 friends.