Miley Cyrus’ parents weren’t on set for topless shots, claims source

you know what that picture is no worse then some of the swim suits i seen on teens so leave her be

I agree with the above comment. Atleast she not on the streets packing a knife and glugging down Buckf*st, so really - what is the problem!

i’ll be the honest one here, since morality is lost now adays. What are you people thinking? She is a fifteen year old girl. she is not an adult. her paretns were absent when these photos were shot, its inappropriate. if everyone acts like its “ok” shes just going to get worse as time goes by. You let one thing go unnoticed, it keeps progressing into bigger things that are wrong. She is suppose to be an “example” and “roll model” to children in America. She really should have stuck up for herself and said no.

I think that your concept of “children”, like that of many others nowadays, is severely flawed and therefore, in a certain respect, immoral. To shed some light… http://family.jrank.org/pages/232/Childhood-Modern-Western-Conception-Childhood.html

I think she should be banned from tv. And billy being out of the country business.

i totally agree with you. they are both really bad singers, and actors. you have said it all!!! but stephanie wow. what a horrible person she is, she thinks that people like us need to get a life and to “lay off of her”, or to “give her a break” cuz she is just “living the dream”

WTF! she made one fricken mistake, that shouldn’t f* up her whole acting career, or her Dad’s. Honsestly…come on! Ya the picture is s****y and disgusting, espesially for her age, but seriously… it was one mistake, maybe if she keeps doing that, then she should be banned, but not because of one. Im sure that if u were under a ton of pressure you would make a mistake too. She said that she’s sorry, so she obviously learned her lesson. so people need to drop this!

Sorry billy should be kicked out of the country business.

In my opinion, she should have showed a little more of her lower back(the lowest part) and a hint of the side of her breast.

you sick-o creep!! wow get a life. you know there is more to life then having girls show their boobs to you!!! your problem is, is that you want to get laid, but no one will let you do them!! creep!!

U sick freak!!! WTF r u thinking?!?! shes f*****g 15 years old!!! u r obviously horney and u want to get laid, but no one will f**k u because your just a lady user! get some fricken morals u disgusting horn dog!

lol you perverted man like she’s 15 and ur probably a 40 year old creep so don’t say stuff like that which may encourage her ok…

well i am on her side and i’m against this too.
yes she IS only 15 and those are pretty bare.
the photos seem like something that about a 30 year old would do.. but on the other hand
why are we making such a big deal out of this time. yes we should address it but yet look at lindsey lohan..britney spears.. these are the people who surround her and who she is competeing with to be the best. i mean all of these girls are barely breaking into their 20’s annd look at the marks they have made. this was definetly not the right choice but it wasnt the first time a celebrity made a big mistake.
we all used to think britney spears was the teen roll model and the all-american girl …look at her now.

lets just hope miley doesnt head down the same path

i just want to say that she is only 15 {miley cyrus] and even thogh her partents arnt their dosnt mean she can do that and i jst wat to say thanks for apologing miley/hannah
mabe celeina gomez will be the next miley and mabbe{!} she is going to be the next britney spears well it only happened one time and i am hoping that it will never happen again

this is so up-setting to me. my child young daughter adores and idolizes hannah montanna/miley cyrus and it is such a shame - the girl is only 15 years old - posing with her rib cage exposed - bad all round!

it was a f*****g mistake, get over is, she said she was sorry

wow hannah!! one time you are for the picture, and then the next you like omg that w***e!! make up your mind already!!

i mean like does anyone else agree with me?!?! some people just need to think about what they are agreeing with and what they are disagreeing with!! i mean really

hey i think thats okay that she did that but when she was doing that did she ever think what her fans are going to think of it and what her parents are going to think of this. I personally for one if she says and acts like a christian then she should show it and i know that it was a very wrong dision. Also there were people in the bible who made mistakes. But some got in trouble by God and some just got told dont do that. but when it all comes to it miley should stop taking the pictures like that and be the normal great girl she always was.

I really don’t see a single thing wrong with what she did. Nothing. She’s not naked (which actually would still be legal) and she’s not engaged in anything sexual. She’s fifteen. That’s far closer to adult than infant, but you people want to keep children childish for as long as possible. Look at history and at the rest of the world… this way of prolonging and defining childhood is very recent and the effect this is having on our children and our culture is simply horrible.

Historical and anthropological evidence suggests that children in other societies and in the past were far more independent and capable of taking care of themselves than Western children are today ( Jackson 1982).

wow sylvia, just go back to your corner! u fricken porn star wanna be

wow, go back to your corner, u fricken porn star wanna b….omg! the picture is disgusting!

The image gives the appearance of post-sex. It conveys a sense of vacancy and blanchness, like most of the blood has been drained from her body. Looks like Lindsay.. I mean Miley had one rough night!

I’m not sure you know what your argument is. Do you think that because she isn’t engaged in a sexual act that this photo doesn’t convey a sexual meaning? Her hair is a mess her lipstick smeared..can you say post-sex!

As for the prolongation of childhood being horrible, are you serious? Research shows the emotional level of people at age fifteen are less prepared for a sexual identity than someone twenty years of age. Actually, sexual identity a young age leads to cognitive difficulties later on, like depression.

The independence argument is flawed as well, children throughout history (and presently in different countries around the world) were faced with harsh economic conditions. Are you suggestion prostitution is what are young girls need, like many young girls in Thailand, Africa, and Mexico need to turn to to survive?

The whole anthropology comment, ummm people only lived for a certain amount of years…like thirty, so it makes sense they participated in sexual acts earlier in life.

The problem most people have with material like this is that women and especially girls are much more than just sexual beings. Questions come to mind such as the messages that are sent to young forming minds. It’s not wrong to want to protect young people from conditions that compromise self worth.

hey, um sylvia…go back to your corner! the picture is disgusting

she loookss so f*****g old in this pic. and her ribs are showing. what is she like 15 shes too young to be posing like this

Maybe all the uproar is jealousy on Billy Ray’s part. There’s a helluva lot of incestual stuff going on this month:

http://www.236.com/news/2008/04/30/attention_worlds_dads_fatherda_1_6191.php
Makes all these pictures seem perfectly normal.

Everyone should just shut up about this because its not like shes revealing anything, and to top it off, there are so much worse pictures of people. ii dont understand why everyone has to target the poor firl just back the f off!

Oh my god u look so ugly here like as if u were dead or an ugly skeleton monkey ong i cant beleive u, u r such a dumb person role model gosh i think u r a s***k and whorey s**t especially all of the other photos i saw of u. And I HOPE THAT U GO STRAIGHT DOWN THE DRAIN. u s****y s**t

Oh yeah does like ur pops mallest u or sumthin just b/c u cant get a guy u shouldnt sleep with ur father or lez mother

i dont think the foto is that bad. the skin that miley is showing could basically be seen if shewas wearing a bikini.so its not abig deal at all.

This picture disgusts me. And so with all her racy pictures. manipulated? come on , this girl already took some s****y pictures and already had man touching her you know what. Its all over the internet . She likes it. This wholesome all american image b******t needs to stop. Sure we can blame the parents for this but guess what, Miley Cyrus likes the idea of being topless. This * apology * thing she did is a BIG HUGE LIE. I will not be surprise if she ends up worse than lindsay or britney or christina or jessica simpson. At this age, sure she is trying to identify his near womanhood but how?? being a s**t is not one of them.

am wiv ya she was my role model once!!!!!!!!